The problem
The port from the boiler plugs off. When it does, the trip is measuring a dead leg, not the furnace.
A furnace pressure trip reads a few inches of water column through a small opening in a wall that has ash, slag or dust on the other side of it. The opening fouls. A plugged tap does not fail to a safe value. It holds whatever pressure was last in the line, so the indication looks normal and the trip stays silent through the one event it exists for.
A calibration at the transmitter does not find this. The transmitter is fine. The fault is between the furnace and the first fitting.
Five things decide whether the tap stays open: the angle of the opening, where the tap sits, how the sensing line runs, whether the line and its clean-out are protected and within reach, and whether anyone cleans it.
1. Angle the opening steeper than the angle of repose
The angle of repose is the steepest slope a pile of loose material will hold before it slides. A tap that rises away from the furnace more steeply than that cannot hold ash. What falls in slides back out.
A level tap, or one that slopes down away from the furnace, is a shelf. Ash settles on it, builds toward the wall and bridges.
PT: pressure transmitter. Schematic, not to scale. The angle of repose depends on the ash or dust. Confirm it for your fuel.
Put a tee at the outer end with a plug in line with the bore, so a rod passes straight through to the furnace. Take the sensing line off the top of the sloped pipe and run it straight up to the transmitter, never off the underside, where ash sliding down the bore would fall into it. Size the tap and the line generously. Small bores bridge sooner, and draft-range signals need larger lines than higher-pressure services.
2. Put the tap on top, not on the bottom
On a duct, hopper or any surface with a floor, everything loose ends up on the floor: ash, scale, wash water, condensate. A bottom tap is the drain for all of it. A top tap has nothing falling into it, and anything that condenses in the line runs back to the process.
PT: pressure transmitter. Schematic, not to scale.
On a vertical wall, keep the tap well above any level where ash, slag or splashing liquid can reach it, and clear of sootblower and burner paths.
3. Run the sensing line up to the instrument
Mount the transmitter above the tap and run the line so it rises all the way. Then condensate and dust have one direction to go: back to the furnace.
A long level run sags between supports. A line that drops to a transmitter below the tap collects everything at the instrument. Either way there is a low point, and at draft pressures a single slug of water in a low point is enough to block or falsify the signal.
Schematic, not to scale.
Transmitter manufacturers give the same rule for gas service: keep the line short, slope it at least 1 in per ft (83 mm/m) down from the transmitter to the process connection, and avoid low points. Support the tubing so it holds that slope when it is hot.
Where a dirty service still fouls a well-built tap, a small continuous purge of clean air can keep it open. Bring the purge in close to the tap, never through the transmitter, and check the reading with the purge on and off. Purge flow through a small line adds its own pressure drop to a signal that is only inches of water column.
4. Keep the line out of harm's way and the clean-out within reach
A shutdown is when sensing lines get damaged.
During an outage the boiler is full of scaffold, rigging and people in a hurry. Small tubing gets stepped on, used as a handhold and crimped. A crimp or a kink is a restriction no rod will clear, and it is usually found after start-up, when the signal is slow or flat.
- Route it out of the way. Keep the line off walkways, ladders and anywhere a scaffold will be built.
- Use the steel. Run it inside the web of an I-beam or column where possible. The flanges guard it.
- Avoid tight bends. A tight bend is where tubing kinks and where ash lodges. Use long sweeping bends, and as few as the route allows.
- Guard what is exposed. Where the line has to cross an open area, give it a cover or a guard.
A clean-out nobody can reach does not get cleaned.
The boiler designer places the tap where it reads furnace pressure best. That is the right first priority, but it is rarely the best place for access. Taps often end up directly below a floor level, where it is close to impossible to reach the plug, let alone get a rod in line with the bore.
Schematic, not to scale. Take-off and transmitter omitted for clarity.
This has to be settled at the design stage, because it is expensive to fix afterwards. Put it in the specification:
- Every tap clean-out reachable from a permanent floor or platform, without a ladder or an added platform.
- No tap directly beneath a floor, grating or beam.
- Clear space in line with the bore for the full length of the rod.
- Sensing lines routed out of traffic, inside structural steel where possible, with no tight bends.
Moving a tap changes what it reads, so agree the location with the boiler designer. On an existing boiler, treat a relocation as a managed change. If the tap cannot be moved, give it permanent access. Until then, the scaffold to reach it belongs in every outage plan.
Use more than one transmitter. Three is best practice
A single transmitter cannot tell you it is wrong. Good practice today is to fit more than one, so that each reading can be checked against another.
| Arrangement | What it gives you |
|---|---|
| One transmitter | Control, indication and trip all rest on one tap. A plugged tap is invisible |
| Two or more | A common arrangement is one transmitter dedicated to the trip and the others used for furnace pressure indication and control. The trip no longer shares a fault with the control loop, and a disagreement shows that something is wrong, though not always which one |
| Three | Best practice. Any one reading can be verified against the other two, so the odd one out is identified. Two-out-of-three logic rides through a single failed or plugged transmitter without losing the protection or tripping the boiler |
Three transmitters on one tap are one measurement.
The extra transmitters are only worth having if each has its own tap and its own sensing line. NFPA 85 calls for furnace pressure on multiple burner boilers to be measured by three transmitters, each on a separate pressure-sensing tap. Comparison and voting protect against a failed transmitter. They do nothing if all three share a tap, a header or a root valve that has plugged.
Walk the lines back from each transmitter to the wall. If they join before they reach the furnace, the redundancy stops where they join.
Use the comparison. Live furnace pressure is noisy. A signal that has gone flat, or lags the others through a load change or a sootblower cycle, is the one with the restricted tap. Alarm on deviation between the transmitters so the control room sees it without having to look.
What the preventive maintenance has to include
Most preventive maintenance (PM) on a furnace pressure trip is a transmitter calibration. That covers the part least likely to be at fault. The PM is not complete unless it includes the tap and the line.
| Task | What it proves |
|---|---|
| Rod the tap through to the furnace | The opening is clear for its full length, not just at the outer fitting. On the run, only under the critical task procedure below |
| Clean or blow down the sensing line | The line is clear from the tap to the transmitter. Isolate the transmitter first and blow toward the furnace, never through the instrument |
| Record what came out | Clear, restricted or plugged. This record sets the interval. If the tap is found restricted, the interval is too long |
| Walk the line, and again after every shutdown | It still rises continuously, with no sags, crimps, kinks, broken supports or new low points. Do it before start-up, while a damaged line can still be replaced |
| Check fittings for leaks | A leak on a draft line pulls the reading toward atmospheric pressure |
| Test the trip from the sensing line | A pressure applied at the tap end reaches the transmitter and trips the final elements. A signal injected at the transmitter proves only the electronics |
| Compare the transmitters after return to service | All of them move together and all of them are live |
Set the interval from what you find. Start at every outage. Shorten it for solid fuel, black liquor and anything else that carries ash or fume, and after any upset that carried material over.
Mark it critical, and treat opening it on the run as a critical task
Identify the furnace pressure trip as a critical trip, in the field and in the maintenance system.
Tag the tap, the clean-out, the sensing line and the transmitter so that anyone who puts a wrench on them knows what they are connected to. Flag the trip as critical in the maintenance system, so its PM cannot be deferred or closed without the tap and line being done.
Take the cap off on the run and the transmitter stops reading the furnace. It reads the boiler house.
The furnace runs slightly negative. With the cap off, the tap is open to atmosphere and the signal moves to outside pressure. Where that signal feeds the furnace pressure control, the controller sees pressure it thinks is too high and ramps up the induced draft (ID) fan to pull it back down. The furnace is then driven more negative than anyone intended, with the flame and the low furnace pressure trip in the way.
Critical task procedure: opening a furnace pressure tap on the run
Write it, approve it, and follow it every time. At a minimum:
- Agree the job with the control room before anyone touches the tap. Hold the load steady for the duration.
- Put the bypass for that trip input on the register, with a compensating measure.
- Set the ID fan to hold the furnace slightly negative and put it in manual before the cap comes off. It stays in manual until the cap is back on.
- Open one tap at a time. Stand to one side of the opening. A furnace that puffs positive will blow hot gas and ash out of it.
- Inspect and rod the tap. Replace and tighten the cap.
- Confirm the reading has come back and agrees with the other transmitters. Then return the ID fan to automatic and clear the bypass.
- Record what was found.
With the ID fan in manual, the board operator is the furnace pressure control. Keep the task short, and do not start it during sootblowing or a load change.
The safest time to clean a tap is with the boiler down. Do it on the run only when the fouling rate leaves no other choice, and never as an unplanned job.
On your next walkdown
- Find every furnace pressure tap. Count the taps, not the transmitters.
- Look at the angle of each opening and where it sits on the wall or duct.
- Follow each line to its transmitter. Note every flat run, sag, drop, tight bend and crimp.
- Stand at each clean-out. Can you reach the plug and get a rod in from the floor, without a ladder?
- Ask when each tap was last rodded, and what came out.
- Check that each furnace pressure trip is tagged as critical at the tap and flagged as critical in the maintenance system.
- Ask for the critical task procedure for opening a tap on the run. If there is none, it is being done without one.
- Read the PM. If it says "calibrate transmitter" and stops, it is not finished.
Sources
- Emerson, Rosemount Annubar Flow Meter Remote Mount Transmitter Installation Options, technical note 00840-0100-4485, October 2019. Impulse piping slope of at least 1 in per ft (83 mm/m); transmitter above the process for gas service.
- Emerson, Rosemount 3051N Reference Manual, 00809-0100-4808 Rev CA, June 2008, impulse piping. Short lines, gas-service slope, no low points in gas lines, no purging through the transmitter.
- Preferred Utilities Manufacturing, The Importance of Sensing Lines to Performance of Boiler Room Instrumentation. Draft transmitters mounted above the tap with the line sloped continuously back to it.
- Preferred Utilities Manufacturing, Keep Your Boiler Room Under Control. Clean-out and drain ports on draft impulse lines.
- Fives North American Combustion, Practical Pointers, taps for measuring chamber (furnace) pressure. A tee and observation port to check for blockage; taps located above where scale or liquid could plug them.
- American Forest & Paper Association, Recovery Boiler Functional Checks, example document, Rev 4. A complete trip test runs from the sensing line through the logic to the final elements, with no plugged sensing lines.
- U.S. Department of Defense, UFC 3-430-11, Boiler Control Systems, section 5-2. Larger connections and sensing lines for low negative pressures.
- Control Global, Prevent pressure transmitter problems, and Plugged Furnace Pressure Connection. Signal noise as a plugging indicator; purge flow adds pressure drop to the reading.
- NFPA 85, Boiler and Combustion Systems Hazards Code. Furnace pressure measurement for multiple burner boilers. Use the edition adopted where the boiler operates.